Hundreds of fallacies are all used to undermine arguments and win over audiences. They are so plentiful that it is nearly impossible to go over each one. Here are a few of the most common fallacies, along with examples of how they are used. This can boost your critical thinking so you know how to spot illogical arguments.
Straw Man Fallacy
A straw man argument is also referred to as a straw person fallacy. This argument takes the most extreme version possible to overdramatize an argument.
For example, if a political candidate supported increased paths to citizenship for immigrants, their opponent might claim they want to completely open the borders. The opponent would paint a picture of America where criminals were allowed to cross into the country and an excessive number of immigrants took American jobs.
Middle Ground Fallacy
A middle-ground fallacy is also known as a false compromise. It is based on the idea that the only way to resolve an issue is by meeting in the middle. There is no winner in the argument and there is no such thing as right or wrong.
For example, John says all cats can fly. Kate says no cats can fly. With the middle ground fallacy, the conclusion is that half of cats can fly — tigers and housecats.
This fallacy forces both parties to accept an incorrect compromise for the argument to end.
False Dilemma Fallacy
Is the idea that there are only two solutions and the opponent needs to choose one. It is a fallacy because it doesn’t recognize the nuance that every problem likely has more than two solutions.
For example, a bride might say that the couple will either have an extravagant wedding or get married at the courthouse. This is a false dilemma because the couple could have a small backyard event, a formal dinner with a few close relations, or elope. There are more options available than are being presented.
Ad Hominem Fallacy
This fallacy is known as attacking the person. Instead of focusing on the issue, the person who uses an ad hominem attack will try to discredit the speaker or the source.
For example, a defense attorney using an ad hominem attack against a doctor as a medical witness might discredit them by pointing out their poor performance in medical school or recent malpractice lawsuits against them. The jury would then question whether the doctor is a valuable source of information.
Bandwagon Fallacy
This fallacy is based on the idea that something is correct or good just because a lot of people support it.
For example, someone who runs a Flat Earth Facebook group might claim that its 5,000 members support this theory. They are trying to use their numbers to create a bandwagon effect so other people will believe this concept.
Fallacy Fallacy
Also known as “argument from fallacy,” this is the idea that because someone made a poor argument or used a logical fallacy, their conclusion is false. An opponent might call out the fallacy and use that to discredit the argument as a whole. People who make good arguments sometimes include fallacies, but their stance can still be true.
For example, you can claim that because your opponent used an ad hominem attack during an immigration debate, their argument for creating a path to citizenship is void.
Burden of Proof Fallacy
With this fallacy, a person will make a claim and then challenge others to disprove it, rather than defending it themselves. This places the burden of proof on the opponent rather than the person who is trying to make an argument.
For example, a person might state that all humans can hold their breath underwater for 10 minutes. They will then challenge other people to disprove that idea instead of providing evidence about lung capacity and research backing up their claims.
Anecdotal Evidence Fallacy
This fallacy relies on individual stories and single instances to support a claim. One anecdote is not considered valid evidence because it is a single instance that doesn’t provide a reasonable sample size.
For example, a person might apply for one job and immediately get hired. They conclude that finding jobs is not hard and no one should be unemployed. This negates evidence that most people apply to several jobs before receiving offers.
Appeal to Authority Fallacy
This is also known as “ad verecundiam” and references an authority figure who agrees with the argument. It doesn’t matter whether that authority figure is right or not — or even if they agree with that idea — their position or perceived expertise is meant to win over the audience.
For example, someone might claim that it is OK to go outside without sunscreen because Gwyneth Paltrow said so. Another person might say they robbed a bank because God told them to.